Abrahamic Monotheism is a theological mugging.
Abrahamic monotheism has long been celebrated as humanity’s great leap forward—an escape from the chaos of many gods to the clarity of one. Yet strip away the rhetoric of revelation, and what you see is less a spiritual gift than a theological mugging. One god barged into the marketplace of deities and ideas, declared himself the only voice, and outlawed every rival. It was not persuasion but extortion: “Worship me, or else.”
The ancients, for all their superstition, at least lived amid plurality. Greek gods fought, reconciled, and gave poets material for tragedy. Vedic deities embodied cosmic forces, sparking philosophical speculation. Egyptian pantheons layered and merged. These were messy systems, yes, but they allowed for imagination and dialogue. There was freedom to think, to borrow, to reinvent.
Abraham’s heirs—Jewish, Christian, and Muslim—closed the gates. A jealous deity reduced infinity to singularity, decreed all other visions false, and demanded total submission. This was not liberation but foreclosure of the mind. Where there had once been polyphony, there was now monotone. And with monotone came violence: temples smashed, libraries torched, dissenters silenced, entire cultures erased. The record is long, bloody, and unmistakable.
Defenders call this unity. But unity under coercion is tyranny; order without freedom is despotism; morality dictated from heaven is not morality at all but infantilization. When a god insists on obedience above understanding, humanity is robbed of its highest gift: the right to reason and to imagine.
The great monotheistic faiths pretend to have given the world law, morality, and meaning. In truth, they extorted compliance, choked creativity, and replaced diversity with dogma. The “one true god” was never a benefactor—it was a theological strong-arm, a celestial mugger. And the price we paid for surrendering to him was incalculable: centuries of stifled thought, burned heretics, and the suffocation of pluralism.
To describe Abrahamic monotheism as a theological mugging is not a metaphor, but a diagnosis. Humanity was jumped in a dark alley of history, beaten into submission, and left to stagger away with its inheritance stolen. The miracle is not that monotheism triumphed, but that, despite it, the human spirit still finds ways to resist.
No Responses