Article18

Egypt, Greece and Rome AND Israel and Arabia

Civilizations are measured not merely by their myths, not merely by the names of prophets or kings preserved in memory, but by the enduring marks they leave upon the earth and upon the human mind. To be remembered as a civilization is to have carved your existence into stone, into marble, into law, into philosophy, into public works that centuries cannot erase. 
Egypt, Greece, and Rome are no longer alive today as political entities, but they are alive in every sense that matters — their ruins still stand, their thinkers still speak, and their inventions still shape the world. By contrast, when one turns to Judaism and Islam, what do we find? Not civilizations, but confessional identities. Not architecture and law codes that endure across the ages, but a reliance on scripture and memory. 
Where Egypt, Greece, and Rome bequeathed to us visible monuments of thought and stone, Judaism and Islam offer primarily the relic of text, and in the case of Islam, the record of conquest. The contrast is so stark it borders on scandalous, and yet it is precisely this scandal we must face if we are to speak honestly about the hierarchy of civilizations.Take Egypt. Long before the Jews inscribed their law on parchment, long before Muhammad raided caravans, Egypt had already built pyramids that defy gravity and time. A single pyramid contains more tonnage of quarried stone than all the synagogues of antiquity combined. The Egyptians not only buried their kings in monumental tombs, but they also encoded their religion, astronomy, mathematics, and mythology into every brick of their structures. 
We can read their hieroglyphs, study their papyri, and reconstruct their rituals. The Sphinx stares at us across millennia as if to say: We built this to last forever. No text, however sacred, can substitute for such defiance of death. Even when Greek conquerors and Roman emperors ruled the Nile, they bowed before Egyptian antiquity. It is no accident that Jews in exile found themselves dazzled by Egypt, and that Islam would later inherit Egypt only to appropriate its legacy. Egypt stands not as a ghost, but as an immortal stone body, visible to any tourist who dares to step into the desert sun.Consider Greece. Out of its rocky soil, with no Nile to sustain it, the Greeks raised temples of proportion and beauty that still shape our architecture. The Parthenon may be battered, but even in ruin, it radiates rationality —the geometry of a people who saw divinity in order. Yet Greece’s true pyramids are not of stone but of thought. Homer gave the West its first epic; Herodotus and Thucydides gave us history as critical inquiry; Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle gave us philosophy as reasoned argument. Even when their marble falls, their words remain unbroken.
 You can topple statues, but you cannot topple Euclid’s proof or Aristotle’s syllogism. This is civilization: the ability to project your voice beyond your grave, not through one tribal scripture but through universal thought. Greece did not conquer the known world militarily as Islam did, but it conquered it intellectually. Every conqueror who came later — Romans, Byzantines, Arabs — could not escape Greek categories of reason. Even the Muslim philosophers who dared to think beyond the Qur’an — al-Farabi, Avicenna, Averroes — were nothing more than translators and commentators on Aristotle. Strip away Greece, and there is no “Islamic philosophy.” Greece is the sun; Islam is only a dim reflection of its light.And Rome. Rome was not the dreamer of pyramids or the discoverer of geometry, but Rome was the great organizer, the codifier, the builder of law and road. Its aqueducts still run, its bridges still stand, its roads still carry cars today. Rome was the architect of civilization, the one that transformed Greek thought into a political structure and Egyptian grandeur into an imperial administration. Roman law still underlies our jurisprudence; Roman republics and senates still echo in our politics. The Colosseum, battered yet unbowed, still tells us what power looks like when it is made of concrete and ambition. Rome, unlike Judaism or Islam, did not live by one book. It created libraries, codified laws, wrote histories, minted coins, and carved triumphal arches. Even its religion, once a hodgepodge of gods, transformed itself into Christianity and carried Roman architecture, Roman law, and Roman organization into the Middle Ages. Rome laid the foundation for the modern world. What did Judaism build? What did Islam build? Rome still stands in our cities, our governments, and our very legal DNA. The same cannot be said of Jerusalem or Mecca.When we turn to Judaism, the silence is deafening. The Jews left no pyramids, no Parthenon, no Colosseum. They left words. Words collected in scrolls, words transcribed into Bibles, words argued over in Talmudic disputations. Their greatest archaeological monument is the Western Wall, and even that is not truly theirs but the leftover retaining wall of a Roman construction project. Remove the Bible, and what remains? A few scattered synagogues, some coins, pottery, and inscriptions. Judaism is not a civilization in the monumental sense. It is a people, a religion, an identity preserved through exile and persecution, through ritual and memory. But a civilization? Civilizations are known by their builders, their thinkers, and their public works. The Jews built no aqueducts, invented no new sciences, erected no empires of stone. They carried their survival not in monuments, but in memory, not in cities, but in texts. And while that is remarkable in its own way, it does not compare to the grandeur of Egypt, Greece, or Rome. A scroll may outlast a building, but a building proves that a people once ruled the earth. 
The Jews ruled only themselves. Islam fares even worse. Arabia before Islam was a desert of tribes, with a few inscriptions and modest temples, but nothing that compares to Egypt, Greece, or Rome. With Muhammad came not a flowering of architecture or philosophy but a sword and a book. The Qur’an is the only monument of Islam’s origin, and it is recited, not built. Islam’s so-called civilization is the record of its conquests. 
Damascus, Baghdad, Cairo, Cordoba, Delhi — all these cities preexisted Islam, and Islam merely conquered and repurposed them. The Dome of the Rock rises not as a creative achievement, but as a defiant symbol of conquest over Judaism and Christianity. The mosques of Damascus and Istanbul are built atop or inspired by Byzantine churches. The Taj Mahal, often regarded as a masterpiece of Islamic genius, is in fact a Persian architectural masterpiece planted on Indian soil. Strip away the conquered civilizations — Persian, Byzantine, Indian, Hellenic — and Islam has nothing but the Qur’an and the memory of jihad.

Its so-called “Golden Age” was nothing more than a translation movement, where Greek, Persian, and Indian knowledge was preserved in Arabic script. Without Greece, there is no Avicenna; without India, no algebra; without Persia, no poetic refinement. Islam is not a creator but an appropriator, not a builder but a conqueror. Arabia itself, the cradle of Islam, remains barren. Show me the archaeological wonders of Mecca. Show me the monuments of Medina. You cannot, for there are none.And yet defenders of Judaism and Islam insist on calling them “great civilizations.” On what grounds? Judaism survives because it invented itself as a portable text. Islam survives because it wielded the sword and absorbed the civilizations it conquered. However, equating them with Egypt, Greece, or Rome is to mock history. Civilizations are weighed not by how loudly they proclaim one God, nor by how zealously they enforce scripture, but by how deeply they carve themselves into the universal memory of humanity.
 When we teach schoolchildren, we teach them about pyramids, philosophers, and Caesars — not about the Western Wall or the Kaaba. When tourists flock, they flock to Athens, Rome, and Luxor — not to Jerusalem or Mecca, unless they go as pilgrims, not as students of civilization. There is a distinction between a religion and a civilization, and it is time we had the honesty to acknowledge it.Egypt, Greece, and Rome still stand, not because their gods were true — those gods are dead — but because their stones and their ideas were immortal. Judaism survives not as a civilization but as a tenacious tribe whose monument is memory. Islam survives not as a civilization but as a conqueror’s creed, living on the skeletons of the nations it subjugated. In the end, what endures is not the zeal of prophets, but the work of builders, thinkers, and engineers. The pyramids do not care who prays in Mecca.
 The Parthenon does not bow to Jerusalem. The Colosseum does not tremble before the Qur’an. Civilization is measured in stone and thought, not in scripture and conquest. By that measure, Egypt, Greece, and Rome stand eternal, while Judaism and Islam shrink into the thinness of text and the brutality of war.